The Next Nightmare is Coming
BitTorrent was NEVER the Performance Nightmare
BitTorrent is a lightning rod on two fronts: it is used to download large files, which
the MPAA sees as a nightmare to their business model, and BitTorrent has been a performance nightmare to ISP’s and some users. Bram Cohen has taken infinite grief for BitTorrent over the years, when the end user performance problems are not his fault.
Nor is TCP the performance problem, as Bram Cohen recently flamed about TCP on his blog.
I blogged about this before but several key points seem to have been missed by most: BitTorrent was never the root cause of most of the network speed problems BitTorrent triggered when BitTorrent deployed. The broadband edge of the Internet was already broken when BitTorrent deployed, with vastly too much uncontrolled buffering, which we now call bufferbloat. As my demonstration video shows, even a single simple TCP file copy can cause horrifying speed loss in an overbuffered network. Speed != bandwidth, despite what the ISP’s marketing departments tell you.